Implausible Denial and What if Grant Shapps was a Health Minister?

I was catching up on Grant Shapps’ interview on the Today programme, where he managed to distract John Humphrys from the key questions for a good few minutes arguing about his diary.

The interview centred on whether he was trying to hide the recent appalling house building statistics behind the Housing Strategy launch or get the strategy out before the stats.

The minister claimed he knew nothing about the figures until after the strategy was launched. Ministers don’t see them before anyone else he told Radio 4 listeners. At the risk of falling into the trap of being too distracted by the ‘process’ – that’s only kind of true.

As with all government statistics, there is a pre-release list of people who get the statistics in advance of their publication. That doesn’t include the minister directly, but it does include his departmental officials and his political advisors. Here’s the copied text from this announcement:


Homes and Communities Agency National Housing Statistics

22 November 2011: Pre-release access list

 Homes and Communities Agency


Chief Executive

Executive Office Manager

Executive Director – Finance & Corporate Services

Executive Director – Programmes & Deputy Chief Executive

Senior Manager – National Communications

 Department for Communities and Local Government


Special Advisor to Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government

Branch Head for Physical Regeneration, Coalfields, Brownfield and Land Stabilisation Programmes

Team Leader: Affordable Housing Delivery and Investment

Policy Officer, Affordable Housing Division

Team Leader: Finance and Governance

Press Officer

 So did all these people who work with the minster on a daily basis, his political advisors who, after all, are supposed to help him manage difficult media issues, did none of them think to mention the imminent release of highly damaging figures? Did he not think to ask?

Perhaps he was all too aware of needing plausible denial, but it all still sounds pretty implausible to me.

Process aside, the most remarkable thing about the interview was his breezy reaction to the figures. Imagine if he was a health minister announcing a 97% fall in cancer survival rates, or an education minister admitting to a 97% drop in GCSE passes, or a Home Secretary announcing that 97% of all passports were not being checked at our borders? He’d at the very least get a harder time from John Humphrys.

The point of a housing minister is to build houses for people. What is the point of one whose ‘reforms’ cause a collapse in house building within a year of taking over?

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Implausible Denial and What if Grant Shapps was a Health Minister?

  1. Pingback: Clever people saying clever things part two « An Unnecessary Role

  2. Pingback: Desperately short of ideas | Red Brick

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s